The intense legal battle between the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and Ripple Labs has kept the crypto industry on the hook. The summary judgment in the XRP lawsuit had given both parties a partial win. However, in the latest move, Ripple filed a detailed response opposing the SEC’s recent motion to compel post-complaint discovery.
Ripple opposes SEC’s motion
As per the latest fillings, Ripple’s response addressed to Judge Netburn, contests the SEC’s motion, which sought to compel Ripple to produce audited financial statements for the years 2022 and 2023. This includes disclosing all post-complaint contracts related to the sale or transfer of XRP to “non-employee counterparties,” and answering an interrogatory about the amount of “XRP Institutional Sales proceeds” received after the filing of the Complaint for certain contracts.
Ripple in the fillings presented two primary reasons for opposing the SEC’s requests. Firstly, Ripple argues that the requests are untimely, asserting that the SEC had ample opportunities during the open fact discovery period to seek the requested information and lacks good cause to do so now. Ripple’s lawyers highlighted previous litigation regarding post-complaint discovery. They tried to indicate that the SEC had previously taken the position that post complaint conduct was inept.
What’s the matter?
The Second reason Ripple contends that the SEC has failed to justify each of its requests on merit. The commission is deeming the information sought irrelevant to the court’s remedies determination. Ripple had expressed concern over the SEC’s intention to seek a summary determination. It is based on whether Ripple’s post-complaint sales constitute investment contracts. Ripple warns against such a summary procedure, emphasizing the need for a full proceeding on the merits to avoid potential delays and burdens.
Moreover, Ripple argues that the SEC’s request for post-complaint discovery, especially given the advanced stage of fact discovery, should be denied. The response concludes by asserting that the SEC’s motion risks depriving Ripple of procedural protections and potentially paving the way for a second full-blown litigation.
It is important to note that Ripple’s native crypto, XRP, has suffered much due to the ongoing legal battle. XRP price is down by more than 12% on the year to date (YTD) basis. XRP’s losing running is continuing as the token has failed to print a green index in a while.
XRP price is down by 10% in the last 30 days. It is trading at an average price of $0.54, at the press time.
