The US’s biggest cryptocurrency exchange, Coinbase is actively dealing with legal challenges pushed by top financial regulators. In the latest approach, the crypto exchange criticized the U.S. Treasury’s proposed rules on crypto mixing. This comes in when Coinbase is already involved in a legal battle with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).
Coinbase didn’t like new crypto mixing rules
Paul Grewal, Chief Legal Officer of Coinbase in a post outlined the exchange’s concerns and objections to certain aspects of the proposed regulations. He mentioned that Coinbase contests the need for new regulations, stating that existing rules already require exchanges to investigate and report suspicious mixing activity. Questioning the necessity of reporting non-suspicious activity, the exchange challenges the Treasury’s motivation for imposing such requirements.
Coinbase is arguing that mandating the reporting of all mixing activities, regardless of their value, would result in bulk reporting of non-suspicious transactions. The company aligns with Congress’s position against such extensive data reporting.
Paul Grewal highlighted that Coinbase recommends that instead of mandatory bulk reporting. He pointed out that the US Treasury should focus on assisting exchanges in meeting their existing obligations regarding the reporting of suspicious activity involving mixing. The exchange advocates for specific guidance, which it deems more effective than broad mandatory reporting rules.
Coinbase’s CLO asked that If a new rule is deemed necessary, he suggests several modifications, including adding a monetary threshold to minimize irrelevant information, making the rule a recordkeeping requirement instead of mandatory reporting, and providing an extended implementation period.
What does the letter suggest?
The crypto exchange submitted a formal written comment to the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) in response to the Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (NPRM). Coinbase acknowledges the potential for the U.S. to lead in digital asset innovation but criticizes the NPRM for two primary reasons.
First, Coinbase argues that FinCEN has not identified a regulatory gap that the NPRM would fill. Existing rules mandate virtual asset service providers (VASPs) to follow comprehensive recordkeeping and reporting rules. Coinbase contends that the NPRM does not explain why these existing requirements are insufficient.
Second, Coinbase expresses concern that the NPRM, in the absence of a regulatory gap, would lead to bulk reporting of data of little help to law enforcement. Despite recognizing that some convertible virtual currency (CVC) mixing is used for legitimate purposes, the NPRM includes an expansive definition of CVC mixing activity without specifying a monetary threshold for reporting.
It seems like the crypto exchange firmly believes that the NPRM should not be finalized in its current form. If FinCEN proceeds with the rule on CVC mixing, Coinbase recommends specific changes to address the outlined concerns and improve the overall effectiveness of the proposed regulation.
